Showing posts with label animal rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label animal rights. Show all posts

Sunday, September 22, 2013

West Hollywood bans the sale of fur. So?

Yesterday West Hollywood's "fur ban" went into effect, to the delight of some animal advocates. However, a closer look at the "fur ban" shows that it's not such a big deal.

The "ban" means that wearing apparel made from animal skins with the fur, wool, or hair still attached cannot be sold in West Hollywood.

Other items made from fur which are not used for wearing apparel are not banned.

Animal skins from which the hair has been removed (i.e. leather, suede) are not banned.

People in West Hollywood are still allowed to wear fur, they just can't sell it.

Retailers who disregard the ban will have to pay a small fine ($250 to $850).

Really, this "ban" is so narrow in its reach I am reminded of Gary Francione's satirical "No Factory-Farmed Small Fish Friday".

So, how is this a win for animals? Will the number of animals killed be affected at all?

At best, some retailers who sell fur will have to relocate their businesses—although some may decide they'd rather pay the fines.

People in West Hollywood who want to buy fur can easily do so, by travelling to a neighbouring city or by shopping onine, although I wonder how much of a demand for fur clothing there ever was in West Hollywood, when they never have snow and their average January low is a mild 9°C.

West Hollywood City Council says on their page about the ban that the ban will "raise awareness" about cruelty to animals and is consistent with their "reputation as a Cruelty Free Zone for animals".

To me, this ordinance is just a way for people in West Hollywood to feel good about being allegedly cruelty free, without having to make any of the significant lifestyle changes (i.e., becoming vegan) that truly being cruelty free would involve. I don't oppose the fur "ban", but I do think it is too narrow in scope to be worth celebrating. I also wonder how much money Last Chance for Animals spent on this campaign, and how many animals could have been saved by putting that money into vegan advocacy, or an animal sanctuary?

Sunday, April 6, 2008

More confused thinking about veganism and honey

Here's another person who identifies as vegan, but would be willing to make an exception for honey (though she hasn't yet). Laura, a university student writing for Taste Better argues that "...bees feel pretty much nothing..." and organic and small-scale beekeeping "isn't really exploitation", and besides "there really is no way... to live without harming others..."

But do bees really feel nothing? Their nervous system is a lot simpler than ours, which leads many to assume that they don't feel as much as we do. But there is no way for us to ever know what it is like perceiving the world from an apian perspective. However, even with such a simple nervous system, bees can communicate with each other in a surprisingly sophisticated way. As vegans, I think we should give bees the benefit of the doubt, just as we do with other invertebrates such as lobsters.

Laura's line of reasoning that organic/small scale beekeeping isn't so bad, and we can't live without harming others, could also be used to justify organic/small scale farming, etc. etc. and often is, though normally by omnivores. In the future, are we going to see omnivores calling themselves "vegan" because they consume only certain animals (fish, invertebrates), or because they "know" that their meat was raised "ethically"?

The misuse of "vegetarian" to include fish and chicken eaters already causes a lot of aggravation to people who really are vegetarian--years ago during a hospital stay, I was served "vegetarian" meals that included large amounts of nasty-smelling dead tuna fish. Now "vegan" is being misused. Already some "vegan" restaurants are serving honey, meaning that even in should-be vegan establishments, vegans have to go through the tedious questions about ingredients.

Go ahead and eat what you want, but if you're eating animal products like honey, please call yourself something other than vegan.

Tuesday, May 17, 2005

Time to think about euthanasia

Jellybean (my betta fish) has been sick for some time now, and today he's looking really bad. On Saturday, he looked constipated again (bulging in front of the anus--but that could also be another tumour) so I'm trying the standard treatment of fasting for a few days and then feeding pieces of a cooked pea (for fibre), which really helped last time. But this time not only is he spending virtually all of his time lying at the bottom of the tank, he is having trouble swimming. When he comes up for air, he has trouble staying upright, sort of staggering all over the place, as though maybe his swim bladder has been affected.

It really looks like the time for euthanasia will be soon (if it hasn't come already). I hate the thought, and my son got furious when I explained that I will have the euthanize Jellybean soon, and what that means. He says I can't because I'm a vegan, and vegans don't kill animals. He wants Jellybean to die "normally".

I'm sure I'm not the only one here who has had to make the euthanasia decision; I've had to make that choice once before. It doesn't get any less painful.

Originally posted on the late great Vegan Porn.

Friday, March 11, 2005

Guillotines

Today I succumbed to temptation and put Google Ads on my site.

Of course, because of the way the ads are chosen, some of them contradict my views.

The worst one is, however, is for guillotines to kill lab animals

They sell two models: a small one for rats and mice, and a larger one which will also handle cats, rabbits, and "larger subjects". And they invite vivs to ask them to custom make an even larger model!

Well, I'm hoping that these dumb ads will help bring out why vivisection is bad.

Originally posted on the late great Vegan Porn.

Friday, August 2, 1996

Veganism better for animals and people

Nicky laughs at the very notion that vegan babies can't be healthy.You know that adopting a vegan diet is best for the animals. But do you have to sacrifice your health to do it? Relax.

When people give up meat they often wonder where they will get their protein, or as one woman asked me, "How do you manage to eat six servings of legumes a day?" In fact, it's hard not to get enough protein. Centring your diet on whole grains, vegetables, and legumes (one or two servings a day) will give you protein to spare. The only ways a vegan could become protein deficient are to not eat enough calories, to eat only fruit, or to eat mostly junk food. (Of course, infants need to be breastfed or given a suitable formula until their digestive system is mature enough to process other foods.)

And forget fancy rules about protein combining, which even the American Dietetic Association acknowledges is unnecessary.

Thanks to the efforts of the Milk Marketing Board, you may think that giving up milk will doom you to osteoporosis. What they won't tell you is that older women in countries that have low milk consumption have less osteoporosis than older women in countries with high milk consumption, like Canada. Why? First of all, calcium is available from many foods besides milk, such as dark green vegetables (except spinach), legumes, nuts, seaweed, and figs. [Since this article was written, calcium-fortified soy drinks and orange juice have become widely available in Canada, making getting enough calcium very easy.] Secondly, a key risk factor for osteoporosis is high protein intake. High as in, eating meat on a regular basis. Excess protein causes calcium to be lost in the urine. Other risk factors are lack of exercise, smoking, soft drinks, and caffeine.

Getting enough vitamin B12 is one worry that may have a grain of truth. This vitamin is made by bacteria, and is abundant in corpses (meat), eggs, and mammary secretions (milk). Where vegans can get it is not so clear. Some vegans have gone for decades with no known source of B12, whereas others have developed a deficiency only a few years after becoming vegan. Since B12 deficiency is serious, play it safe and take a 25 microgram supplement every week. (Look for the words cobalamin or cyanocobalamin on the label.) [Or use a soy drink fortified with vitamin B12.]

Hopefully I've reassured you that veganism won't kill you. Now here's the good news--unless you're living on pop and chips, veganism is healthier!

Many of the most dreaded diseases of our society, including breast cancer, colon cancer, heart disease, non-insulin dependent diabetes, and stroke, are linked with the consumption of animal products. By becoming vegan, you can reduce the risk dramatically.

"Couldn't I just use leaner meats and skim milk?" you ask. That might do some good, but not as much as becoming vegan would. Evidence is mounting that animal protein is also a significant risk factor. In addition, plant foods contain higher levels of antioxidants, substances which protect the body from free-radicals and thus slow down the aging process and the progress of some degenerative diseases. And animal products contain none of the dietary fibre which is so important.

And you don't have to wait decades to see benefits from your vegan diet.

For example, if you've been starving yourself to become fashionably slim, starve no more! Vegans tend to be slimmer than nonvegans, because we eat more carbohydrates, which rev up our metabolisms, and because with few exceptions vegan food is lower in fat. What you eat is more important than how much.

The benefits I have noticed since becoming a vegan four years ago are typical. My cellulite disappeared, my painful ear infections are gone for good, and the mucus that used to clog my throat is a thing of the past. Provided I avoid french fries (my weakness), I have no PMS and no menstrual cramps. And best of all, I have much more energy as a vegan than I did as a meat-eater or lacto-ovo-vegetarian.

So what are you waiting for? Being vegan doesn't just save animals' lives--it can save your life, too!


This article originally appeared in a slightly different form in the February 8, 1996 issue of The Varsity, a student newspaper at the University of Toronto . Reproduced with permission.